Q. Will you look at my manuscript/portfolio and give me feedback?

Unfortunately I lack the time to critique writing or view online art. I'm already a member of several wonderful collab and critique groups and encourage you to find your own supportive group. I found mine through the SCBWI (http://scbwi.org/) forums and at conventions. If you're in Canada, you should also check out CANSCAIP (http://www.canscaip.org/) events.

I already have my own critique groups (MiG Writers and Torkidlit friends for my writing, for example) and value their opinion highly. It took me a while to find the right group of people; I found some of them through organizations like the SCBWI and CANSCAIP -- either through message boards or events. Torkidlit was founded by Claudia Osmond, who approached us via Twitter.

It takes me considerable time and effort to do a proper critique. There are many qualified people out there who would be willing to help critique and edit your work for a fee.

I strongly recommend that you find your own group of writers or artists, and find a critique group that suits your own situation. If you're willing to pay a fee, ask around to get recommendations for good editorial services.

Related FAQ entries:

Where else can I find useful info about writing & illustrating for young people?

Here are some articles that might help:

The Route To Publishing As An Author/Illustrator - Eliza Wheeler on KidLitArtists.com

Critique Groups: How To Find Your Dream Team - Sharla Rae

Finding A Critique Group - Picture This! blog (picture book writing)

The Writer's Craft - Writing Critique Groups

Top 10 Tips For A Critique Group

How To Form Your Own Painting Critique Group

Last updated on August 12, 2015 by Debbie Ohi