How a rejection got me a book deal: My career-changing SCBWI Summer Conference experience
Saturday, September 4, 2010 at 3:55PM PLEASE NOTE: This article has moved to the KidLitArtists.com site. This page will eventually go away, so please do adjust your bookmarks to: http://kidlitartists.blogspot.com/2010/09/how-rejection-got-me-book-deal-my.html - Thanks!
(Reprinted with permission from the SCBWI Illustration Committee Blog)
It all began with a rejection.
Originally, I wanted to participate in the manuscript critique program at the SCBWI Summer Conference in L.A. This year, I was excited about submitting pages from a new project: a middle grade humor-mystery illustrated by cartoons. Worked hard to get the pages finished, and then paid to have it couriered it to the SCBWI office to make the deadline.
Sadly, I had misread the submission rules. The hardworking staff at the SCBWI office called to let me know. Illustrations were not allowed for any type of manuscript submission and no, not even a one sample illustration at the end. Disappointed, I told them that I had to withdraw from the critique program.
When I told my illustrator friend, Beckett Gladney (also see her personal blog & Etsy shop), she suggested I submit something to the Illustrator Portfolio Showcase at the convention. I told her I wasn't good enough, but she and my author/illustrator sister Ruth Ohi disagreed. My next excuse: lack of time. Beckett said she'd help me.
I didn't have a proper online portfolio, so Beckett went into my Flickr account and chose images she thought were my strongest. Then she printed them out and created a gorgeous custom-made cover for my portfolio (she sells others in her Etsy shop), if anyone's interested). The night before the Portfolio Showcase, we spread the pictures out on the floor and decided on the order.
To my utter shock, I ended up winning an Honor Award (one of the two runners-up) and a Mentorship Award.
Because I hadn't read the schedule properly, I missed the award announcements. I arrived after they were over, and started browsing porfolios. Oh geez, I thought. These are all so good. What was I THINKING, entering my work in this event? I purposely didn't look for my own portfolio because I was too embarrassed.
Then Beckett grabbed me, all excited, and said that my portfolio was up front on the winners' tables. At first I thought there must have been a mistake. Then I was convinced I was dreaming (seriously, no lie).
Because here's the thing: up to this weekend, I had always considered myself mainly a WRITER. Yes, I did webcomics and some client work, but never thought about doing children's book illustration because I had no art training. 
The next morning, the six chosen mentees met with the six mentors for our one-to-one portfolio critique sessions: Cecilia Yung, Art Director and VP at Penguin Young Readers; Pat Cummings, Illustrator, Writer, and Instructor at Parsons; Priscilla Burris, National Illustrator Coordinator; David Diaz, Award Winning Illustrator; Bridget Strevens-Marzo, International Illustrator Liason; and Rubin Pfeffer, Agent at East/West Literary Agency.
At first I was SO intimidated, but then forgot about being nervous once the sessions started because I was too busy absorbing all the feedback and advice about what worked in my portfolio, what didn't, and what I could do to improve. And throughout it all, I couldn't help but get excited. And I mean really, really excited.
After the mentor sessions, we mentees decided to get together on our own and compare notes as well as get to know each other a bit better. The other mentees were: Ashley Mims, John Deininger, Andrea Offermann, Eliza Wheeler and Kimberly Gee.
We all got along really well. So well, in fact, that we've kept in touch even now that the conference is over. We exchange news, advice and info through a mailing list, and we've even launched our own blog.
In fact, this is the first public announcement about our brand new blog, WHERE THE SIDEWALK BEGINS. In addition to posting updates about our illustration projects, we're also going to share info about what we learned during our mentorship sessions as well as other tips, resources and news of interest to children's book illustrators.
But wait! There's more!
One of the Portfolio Showcase judges was Justin Chanda, publisher for Simon & Schuster Books For Young Readers, Atheneum Books For Young Readers, and Margaret K. McElderry Books. The day after the Showcase, Alice Pope told me that Justin was looking for me.
When I found myself in the front row just before one of Justin's panels, my seat mates (whom I had just met) helped me work up the courage to go up and introduce myself to the publisher. 
Justin sent me the unedited picture book story, which I LOVED and he and my agent, Ginger Knowlton from Curtis Brown, worked out the details. Then (YAY) I was told I could make the news public. So for those of you who haven't yet heard, I'm going to be illustrating a picture book by writer/comedian/actor Michael Ian Black, due out from Simon & Schuster in 2012.
Not only that, but another publisher who had seen my portfolio is interested in seeing any picture book stories I've written. SO excited about the possibility of writing -and- illustrating my first picture book.
None of this would have happened had it not been for the SCBWI Illustrator Portfolio Showcase. That weekend was a career-changer for me. It opened my eyes to opportunities I had never considered before. It gave me the opportunity to learn from industry pros one-on-one; several of the mentors have asked me to keep in touch and update them on my progress.
I'm also learning from the other mentees, who are sharing advice as well as encouragement. I'm excited about our new blog.
My advice to illustrators AND writers out there:
1) Be open to new career opportunities.
2) Don’t get in a creative rut. Push yourself to venture out of your comfort zone on a regular basis (or have a supportive friend like Beckett Gladney to help do the pushing).
3) If you're interested in writing or illustrating for children, join the SCBWI.
4) And getting back to how this all began ... Try not to let rejections get you down. You never know what opportunities they'll bring. It turns out that getting my mss rejected was a good thing, since conference attendees can only participate in the mss critique OR the portfolio showcase, not both.
So ... if I HADN'T been rejected by the mss critique program, then I wouldn't have been able to participate in the Illustrator Portfolio Showcase even if I had wanted to.
And to the SCBWI, especially the SCBWI Illustration Board:
THANK YOU!
-- Debbie Ridpath Ohi
Reader Comments (39)
The only time we know our work will come to nothing is when we stop trying. Joe Haldeman was turned down more than a dozen times before Forever War found a publisher, and went on to win both the Nebula and Hugo awards. Nine British publishers rejected J.K. Rowling’s first Harry Potter novel. Frank Herbert’s Dune received thirteen rejection slips. Steve Berry told me in January 2010 email that it took him 12 years and 85 rejections before an editor said yes. Rudyard Kipling received this personalized rejection slip early in his career: “I’m sorry, Mr. Kipling, but you just don’t know how to use the English language.” Theodore Geisel’s first children’s book was turned down by twenty-three publishers before Macmillan accepted it, and suggested he use a pseudonym, so Geisel adopted the peculiar name Dr. Seuss for And to Think I Saw it on Mulberry Street. Richard Hooker worked seven yeas on his oddball, wonderful novel, only to have it rejected by twenty-one publishers. The books was M*A*S*H. Finding an agent and publisher is like looking for our lost car keys: they are in the last place we look.
This is an inspirational post. It goes to show that when The door closes, God always opens a window. We need to recognize our Windows of Opportunity - or at least, have friends that recognize and support our potential. Congratulations.
I just found this post by accident and I'm so glad I did! What an inspirational story and a happy ending for such a well-deserved accomplished person like yourself. I'm a big fan of your drawings that I keep seeing at random places like The Writer magazine. I'm looking forward to being a new reader on this blog as well. Congratulations!
Fun, fun + inspiring read! Thank you and good luck!
Hi Debbie,
Well done. That's brilliant for you! Funny how things turn out sometimes!! :) Abi x
Congratulations - Enjoyed your inspiring story!!!!
I remember you when you were the editor of the top writing newsletter: Inkspot. Ironically, I have also moved from nonfiction writing to art.
Cool!! Congratulations on your book deal, looks fun!!
awesome story, debbie! you've inspired me to reactivate my membership and start working hard again!! congrats and i'm looking forward to seeing your new work!!
What an inspiring and heart-warming story. I remember you from your Inkspot days. I've been a writer for most of my life and an artist for the past ten years.
I loved this story! Mega congratulations!!!! Cheers!
Congratulations!! What a wonderful story.
Brittany Roshelle
The Write Stuff
So happy for you, Debbie- and what an inspirational story - thanks so much for sharing...sounds like one of those urban legends ;-)
Dear Debbie,
I love your new book "I'm Bored". I had the honor of viewing it at the SCBWI conference gala. Thank you for sharing. It was great meeting you. Thanks for the hug!
All the best,
Lily Erlic
Children's Author
Finger Rhymes for Manners
Hey Debbie,
Check out the photos from the SCBWI conference. Your book is in the picture too!
http://www.scbwi.org/My-Photos.aspx
All the best,
Lily